Bill De Blasio is the Right Kind of “Racist”

Policies like stop-and-frisk aren't just a black problem, they're everybody's problem.

  • Share
  • Read Later
Kathy Willens / AP

New York City Democratic mayoral hopeful Bill de Blasio embraces his son Dante, left, daughter Chiara, second from left, and wife Chirlane McCray, right, at his election headquarters after polls closed in the city's primary election Tuesday, Sept. 10, 2013, in New York.

Bill de Blasio’s victory in the Democratic mayoral primary last night may well be the beginning of New York City finally turning a corner for real on race – and possibly serving as a beacon for the rest of the country.

Of course, to Mayor Bloomberg, de Blasio’s calling attention to his black wife, mixed-race son with the big Afro, and the city’s stop-and-frisk policies was “racist.” Dead wrong – Bloomberg has done a great deal right for New York but he has a tragically tin ear on the race thing.

Few understand how central excessive stop-and-frisk policies are in teaching blacks and Latinos that they are aliens in their own land. Wonder why so many of them think of racism as a clear and present danger in 2013? Ask them and count the seconds until the cops come up.

Opinions will differ as to whether de Blasio should utterly discontinue stop-and-frisk as he has suggested, and doing as much stopping and frisking on the Upper East Side as in Bushwick would be performance art. However, under Bloomberg the policy has simply morphed far beyond the reasonable. No matter how you look at it, 120,000 black and Latino boys between 14 and 18 stopped in New York in 2012 was not a society functioning properly.

(MOREBreaking Up With Bloomberg)

As such, de Blasio placing his brown-skinned son in a tide-turning commercial was not a callow stunt. It was an articulate statement of intent about a crucial issue. It was more meaningful than Bill Thompson’s just being black himself, and it’s a sign of the times that the black community registered its meaning and gave so much of their vote to de Blasio despite his whiteness. De Blasio’s family situation shows that the stop-and-frisk problem is everybody’s issue, not just a “black” problem.

That’s because a policy that makes black boys grow up thinking of white people as a menace is a policy that creates more of the kind of black men people are weary of. Say you grow up feeling under siege by police. The cops are authority, and it’s a short step from distrusting them to distrusting society beyond the hood. Pretty soon you have a tacit idea that the rules shouldn’t apply to you, at least not as much as they do to other (that is, white) people. As such, for reasons not your fault, you have become a nuisance. You seem uncivil, uncooperative. You are alienated and you have a chip on your shoulder.

The Mayor and Police Commissioner Ray Kelly tell us stop-and-frisk has been key to getting the city’s crime rate so much lower than it used to be – but no one has shown that the rates had to be this viciously high. De Blasio will likely soon be in a position to try an experiment this city – and nation – desperately needs to carry out.

MOREThe Ad That Won the New York Mayor’s Race

If one generation of black and Latino boys grow up without a sense of white cops as an enemy barging in on innocent people’s lives on a regular basis, then they will become a generation of black and Latino adult men without the “don’t tread on me” demeanor that tends, in vicious cycle style, to attract and stir up the exact kind of treatment that created it. Let’s stop the cycle.

Bill de Blasio’s reign could be the beginning of something big in this city. If what he’s about is “racist,” then let’s have more of it.


7 comments
coldstoli
coldstoli

Blub blub professor of "comparative literature"  (whatever the hell that is) be all qualified to speak from his angry black troll heart about raycissism and sheet.  Never mind the Asians, the Poles, the Italians, the Morroccans, the Indians, the Puerto Ricans, etc. etc. etc.  NYPD beez anti black pure and simple and I don't need to "compare" that to no other literature, gnomewhatI'msayin'? And I gots the tenure from the federally-loan funded Harlem U to prove it!

TAS
TAS

Like McWhorter & read a lot of his books...But, while "stop & frisk" is a close call & difficult issue, would disagree with his cause & effect argument that black youth's disrespect for laws & authority springs from aggressive policing. Think it may be the other way around...In this regard, he fails  to address why, in places like Chicago,  Wash DC & other cities, where there is a lack of aggressive policing due to incompetence or indifference, the youth there have absolutely no respect for the community & its laws & the communities are a mess &  falling apart as a result,  with the "violence rate" there many times the rate in other areas ... And it is innocent minority  citizens in those communities who are the primary victims...Until we have concrete examples of positive effects for a different kind of policing  in American cities, maybe we should stick with what works... Everything that goes wrong in the black community is not always the result of racism & white oppression as many claim...maybe ...not even most things...

cjh2nd
cjh2nd

"Few understand how central excessive stop-and-frisk policies are in teaching blacks and Latinos that they are aliens in their own land."

last time i checked, a lot of those latinos are aliens (of the illegal variety) in a land that is not, in fact, theirs


LupitaGonzales
LupitaGonzales

Since the government is otherwise helpless when it comes to controlling the illegal use of guns how else is the society suppose to control the use of guns? 

Openminded1
Openminded1

Here goes Mcwhorter again with his BS rhetoric . What a title the right kind of racist, what the hell is the right kind of racist? There is no such thing as the right kind of racist. a racist is a racist. Mr de Blasio is not a racist at all, he will be great for new yorkers a man who understands racism from both worlds as I do and guys like Obama should but doesnt. Good like BILL I hope you win in NOV.

BSmike
BSmike

@Openminded1 why do you think he put the word "racist" in quotes?  Bloomburg said that DeBlasio talking about his family was "a form of racism," and McWhorter was just taking off from that point, hence the quotes.  


Openminded1
Openminded1

Giving McWhorter the benefit of the doubt you maybe correct. but with is race baiting past you never know, i do know it was sarcastic and that is ok because so am I. either way hope DeBlasio  wins he will be good for the city.