Gang Rape Conviction in India Creates Unequal Protection

The New Delhi rape victim deserved justice, but she only got it because she gained celebrity status

  • Share
  • Read Later
Danish Siddiqui / Reuters

Demonstrators hold candles during a candlelight vigil for the gang rape victim who was assaulted in New Delhi, on Dec. 30, 2012.

As an Indian court handed down death sentences to those accused in the brutal gang rape and murder of the 23-year-old physiotherapy student in New Delhi last December, people distributed sweets on the street and tweeted “justice served.” The appeals will drag on for a while, but in a country where a typical rape case takes nine years, the model speed with which this case was settled has elicited jubilation. Yet, if anything, this case highlights the problems with India’s criminal justice system, not its strengths.

The main — if not the only — reason why the wheels of justice moved so swiftly this time was the domestic outrage and the international headlines this case generated. This episode got the attention of India’s middle classes because they couldn’t hide behind any special biographical detail about the victim or her behavior to tell themselves that this couldn’t happen to them. She wasn’t some brazen hussy from the village traipsing around town alone late at night. No, she came from a “respectable” family, was appropriately dressed and had a male friend escorting her back from the mall where they had gone to catch The Life of Pi.

(MORE: Gang Rapists Sentenced to Death, But India’s Denial Continues)

And it captured the imagination of the international community because of its horror-movie aspect: An unsuspecting couple climbed into a bus, the lights dimmed and unspeakable horrors unfolded on them for several hours as they drove past multiple checkpoints in a bustling metropolis. India’s national prestige was on the line.

But the real test of a justice system is how it deals with cases away from the limelight involving ordinary citizens. And on this score, India’s system is nowhere close to civilized standards. In this case, for the first time ever, prosecutors actually matched the dental impressions of the accused to the bite marks found on the victim’s body. But in most rape cases in India, this never happens. That’s because the Indian police is poorly trained and unaware even of the elementary forensic tools at its disposal and there are 29 forensic labs for 1.2 billion people, not even close to what would be needed to support meticulous forensic work for the 95,000 rape cases languishing at any given time. This is ironic, to say the least, for a country that has aspirations to become the global technological superpower some day.

What’s more, this case was settled in one of New Delhi’s five fast track courts that were created specially to deal with rape cases in the wake of this episode. These courts, where judges are required to hold hearings almost every day instead of adjourning for months at a time, are a popular solution in a country whose judicial system suffers from notorious bottlenecks. But the fundamental promise of a liberal democracy is to provide equal protection under the law. Carving out special categories of crimes for special treatment through special courts is inherently discriminatory.

When a good is scarce, its possession becomes a status symbol. And, in India, police protection is the ultimate status symbol. There are 129 police officers per 100,000 civilians, the second-lowest figure of 50 countries surveyed by the United Nations, just above Uganda. Ordinary citizens confronting criminal situations don’t have a prayer of getting the police to respond in anything resembling a timely fashion. Yet the central and state governments have created special categories of people for lavish protection. Public officials and wealthy movie stars deemed to be in the second highest “Z category,” for example, were granted 22 personnel at taxpayer expense as part of their security detail until recently when this was scaled back.

The New Delhi rape victim deserved justice. She got it only because she gained celebrity status. But if that’s the bar that her fellow sisters will have to meet, her case will be not just a tragedy — but also a travesty.

8 comments
rorschach13
rorschach13

These scumbags will be fast tracked to the gallows because those in power want this case to burn out and then disappear so that things can go back to exactly the way they were before...because actual change is hard. 

So...it's a little bit like the way the U.S. reacts after a mass shooting...the media talks about how societal attitudes towards guns need to change, people seem temporarily shocked and horrified and politicians promise to actually do something about a society drowning in firearms...and then...once the story slips from the the headlines...it's like it never even happened.

MishtiJuno
MishtiJuno

Very good article! Women, girls and children need better protection and respect in India and other parts of the world.

Openminded1
Openminded1

No wonder so many women from India move to the USA less chance of being raped by the male chauvinist pigs of india, with there double standards and no respect for women.

mdzakiansari
mdzakiansari

Very rightly said. And horrifying though this case was, it has not changed the Indian male mindset.

Openminded1
Openminded1

@SarahConfran @Openminded1 we can throw stones sarah, as a 30 year police veteran who worked sex crime for 4.5 years i can tell you the only reason some rapist do not go to jail here is because of the victims not coming forward and not wanting to re-live the trauma. In india the men as a rule are chauvinistic . The almost condone rape there.

Openminded1
Openminded1

@NYC_UES @Openminded1 not a sweeping statement, a statement of fact reference to the male population of India. You are very naive, traveling to india as a tourist you were most likely in areas that were mandated safe for americans stupid enough to want to vacation in India. India has no middle class, it is wealthy or poor mostly poor. that is why we have so many people from india living here. 

NYC_UES
NYC_UES

@Openminded1  You must have worked on some kind of joint sex crimes division for the US and India to make such a sweeping statement :)

Just as Indians don't read about an unfortunate event and label ALL Americans to be a certain way, we should also refrain from making broad generalizations. I've traveled to India and it's a very diverse society and just as the US, attitudes toward women differ based on level of education, income, culture and nurture. This article seems to be making a point about the legal system, which is definitely archaic and needs an overhaul.