Last Halloween, I felt like the victim in a horror film. I was the guy ignoring the wise warning of my older next-door neighbor. You’ll need at least 15 bags to survive, he told me, with a hollow look in his eyes. Maybe more.
But while grocery shopping on a Saturday afternoon, I threw a mere eight small bags of candy into the cart. That would have been more than enough to satisfy the number of trick-or-treaters in my old neighborhood, a crowded section of apartments and duplexes in L.A.’s Miracle Mile. Little did I know that in moving into a house in the heart of the San Gabriel Valley, my family and I had crossed a dividing line unmarked on any map, a line that becomes clear only when the ghosts and ghouls show up on your door on the night of October 31. We had relocated from a Halloween desert to a Halloween destination to which people travel to do their trick-and-treating.
Yes, Halloween may once have been a neighborhood event, the sort of night when communities come together to share candy with their children and cheerfully tolerate the impromptu art installations of hormonal teens armed with shaving cream and eggs. But those days are long gone. Halloween, like too much else, has become aspirational. Many Americans are more than willing to get in the car or hop on the bus in search of a better Halloween a couple of towns over.
There is data on this, as there seems to be on everything, and the folks at Zillow, the housing data firm, have compiled an index of the country’s best neighborhoods for trick-or-treating. It is based on four criteria: high home values (rich people = better candy), high population density (making trick-or-treating more efficient), walkability, and low crime.
The best city in the country for trick-or-treating is San Francisco, where neighborhoods like Noe Valley go all out. Boston (top trick or treat neighborhood: West Roxbury) is ranked second; Honolulu (Moanalua) is third; and cities from every region in the country, save Texas, are represented in the top 20. Los Angeles, where I’m from, ranks sixth.
This sort of thing, like Halloween itself, is at once fun and scary. The fun part is the mixing of children and families across geographic and other lines for at least one night. Warriors against income inequality can take comfort in having at least one holiday that’s redistributionist. The scary part is that so many of us prefer to take candy from better-heeled strangers rather than from our own neighbors. That’s how weak the bonds of community are. In California, home to four of the top 12 trick or treating cities on Zillow’s list, we are less likely to know our neighbors or work on community projects than people in other states. Halloween is one natural opportunity to meet the people down the block, but only if you stay in your neighborhood.
You might think Halloween wanderlust would weaken, with crime down and gas prices up. But no. Streets like mine—upper-middle-class, low-traffic, with plenty of parking—continue to be deluged. A certain holiday spirit can also be part of the draw. In my town in greater L.A., South Pasadena, a local theater has been turned into a haunted house, and there are at least two pumpkin patches nearby. This year, Halloween has been declared John Carpenter Night, in honor of the director of 1978 slasher classic Halloween, which was filmed in town. It was about a child murderer who escapes from a mental hospital and—demonstrating a refreshing commitment to community—returns to his old neighborhood to terrorize teenage babysitters. (Maybe that’s why it’s so hard to hire one around here.)
My own night of horror came last Halloween. By 5:30 pm, every parking spot on my street was taken, and there were lines at almost every door. It was a great scene; I met families from 20 miles away. But I ran through the eight candy bags in half an hour. Then I drove out in desperate search of more supplies. Two grocery stores had been cleaned out; the drugstore had 10 bags of mini-chocolate bars, all of which I bought. Those only lasted one more hour. My night ended in disgrace before 8, when I hung an “Out of Candy” sign on the door.
I’m still haunted by that night. So this year, I’m planning to brave the impossibly crowded local Costco, where parking is like a John Carpenter movie, and buy 20 industrial-strength bags of candy. I just hope it will be enough to sate the vampires and zombies who come knocking on the door.
Joe Mathews writes the Connecting California column for Zocalo Public Square for which this piece was originally written.